Sports

Most controversial red cards in the Champions League

Explore the most contentious and debated sendings-off in Champions League history. This ranking delves into the red cards that sparked controversy, refereeing discussions, and intense reactions from players and fans alike. Discover key moments where referee decisions altered the course of crucial UEFA Champions League matches. Relive the plays that are still debated today among experts and followers of European football.

0100% verified
  1. 1

    Gianluigi Buffon's sending off (Real Madrid vs Juventus, Champions League 2018)

    0 Global Votes

    Buffon's red card in the final minutes of a decisive match, after vehemently protesting a controversial penalty, encapsulates the frustration and passion of elite football. This incident marked a dramatic end for Juventus's participation in that edition and for Buffon's Champions League career with the Old Lady.

  2. 2

    Cristiano Ronaldo's Red Card (Juventus vs Valencia, Champions League 2018)

    0 Global Votes
    • Controversial red card incident

    This red card was highly controversial due to its seemingly mild nature, sparking a major debate about the severity of refereeing decisions in high-profile matches. It occurred at a significant moment, Cristiano Ronaldo's Champions League debut with Juventus, which added more attention to the incident.

  3. 3

    Arturo Vidal's Red Card (Bayern Munich vs Real Madrid, Champions League 2017)

    0 Global Votes
    • Harsh sending off

      (+1)

    Arturo Vidal's red card is remembered as one of the most unfair, as the second yellow was for a tackle where he seemed to touch the ball first. This incident was a turning point in a tie already marked by controversial refereeing decisions that favored Real Madrid.

  4. 4

    Juan Cuadrado's Red Card (Juventus vs Real Madrid, Champions League 2017 Final)

    0 Global Votes
    • Incident led to a controversial red card

      (+2)

    This red card in a Champions League final is notable for the lightness of the action that provoked it, a slight push on Sergio Ramos. The perception that Ramos exaggerated his fall added a layer of controversy, making this a moment remembered for its refereeing strictness on the biggest stage.

  5. 5

    Jens Lehmann's sending off (Arsenal vs Barcelona, 2006 Champions League Final)

    0 Global Votes
    • Became the first player sent off in a European Cup final

      (+3)

    This was the first red card in a Champions League final, making it a historic and controversial milestone. The controversy centered on whether the referee should have applied the advantage rule, as Lehmann's professional foul prevented a goal that was scored in the same play.

  6. All the rankings you can imagine

    Thousands of verified votes to discover the best. Your vote here counts

  7. 6

    Didier Drogba's Red Card (Chelsea vs Manchester United, Champions League 2008 Final)

    0 Global Votes
    • Second player ever red-carded in a Champions League final

      (+1)

    Drogba's red card in the final minutes of a Champions League final, for an act of frustration, is an iconic and controversial moment. It left Chelsea with ten men just before the penalty shootout, depriving them of their main taker and adding drama to the defeat.

  8. 7

    Fernando Torres's Red Card (Atlético de Madrid vs Barcelona, Champions League 2016)

    0 Global Votes
    • Gave his side the lead before being sent off

    Fernando Torres's red card is widely considered an unfair turning point in a crucial tie, as the second yellow was very strict. This incident generated great outrage at Atlético de Madrid and among its fans, who felt that the decision benefited Barcelona.

  9. 8

    Robin van Persie's Red Card (Arsenal vs Barcelona, Champions League 2011)

    0 Global Votes
    • Considered one of the most controversial refereeing decisions in Champions League history

      (+1)

    This red card is one of the most cited as 'unfair' in Champions League history, due to the disproportionate sanction for an apparently involuntary action. Van Persie's argument of not having heard the whistle at Camp Nou added a layer of disbelief to the referee's decision.

  10. 9

    Remo Freuler's Red Card (Atalanta vs Real Madrid, Champions League 2021)

    0 Global Votes

    Freuler's early red card in a round of 16 match was a decisive factor that left Atalanta with one man less for almost the entire game. This decision generated an intense debate about the severity of direct red cards in crucial stages of the competition, affecting the balance of the tie.

  11. 10

    Lloyd Kelly's Red Card (Juventus vs Galatasaray, Champions League 2026)

    0 Global Votes

    This very recent red card stands out due to the perception of refereeing inconsistency in the Champions League, as an accidental contact led to such a severe sanction. The outrage generated by the decision to send off Kelly for a fortuitous play makes it one of the most controversial of the current season.

  12. 11

    Santiago Hezze's Red Card (Barcelona vs Olympiacos, Champions League 2025)

    0 Global Votes
    • Controversial red card incident

      (+2)

    This equally recent red card was labeled 'unfair' by many analysts, who argued that the action did not warrant a second yellow card and that there was an 'excess of theatrics' from the opposing player. The decision benefited Barcelona at a key moment, making it highly controversial and relevant.