Discover the top-rated creamy eyeliners on the market, perfect for achieving a smooth application and long-lasting finish. This selection features waterproof and smudge-proof options, ideal for any makeup style. Find highly pigmented formulas that glide on effortlessly, suitable for both subtle and dramatic eye looks. Explore the best brands and expert-recommended products to enhance your gaze with ease and precision.
Waterproof
(+4)
This eyeliner stands out for its creamy, soft texture, which allows for easy application and exceptional blending to create various looks. It offers high pigmentation and intense color with a single stroke, making it very versatile for precise lines or smokey effects.
Voted best eyeliner in Glamour 2021 Beauty Awards
(+4)
This eyeliner stands out for its exceptionally creamy formula that glides smoothly onto the eyelid without tugging, offering effortless application. Its rich pigmentation and ability to wear for up to 16 hours, being waterproof and smudge-proof, make it a reliable choice for long-lasting wear.
Applies very smoothly
(+4)
This eyeliner stands out for its soft, buttery kohl texture that glides on effortlessly, allowing for a creamy, tug-free application. Its formula delivers rich color and a silky-smooth finish that defines and shades eyes with ease, perfect for smudged and smoky looks.
Lasting and doesn't sharpen down to nubs
(+4)
This eyeliner stands out for its exceptionally creamy formula and smooth application, gliding effortlessly over the eyelids without tugging. It delivers intense pigmentation and long-lasting wear, being both waterproof and smudge-proof, ensuring a flawless finish throughout the day.
Rich, lasting color
(+4)
This Revlon eyeliner features a creamy formula that glides on smoothly without tugging, allowing for comfortable and precise application. Its ability to last up to 24 hours, coupled with its waterproof and smudge-proof properties, ensures intense, fresh color all day, ideal for looks requiring durability.
All the rankings you can imagine
Thousands of verified votes to discover the best. Your vote here counts
Creamier formula with more color payoff
(+4)
This eyeliner features a creamy, ultra-pigmented formula that glides on smoothly, allowing for effortless application on both the lash line and waterline. Its soft texture and smudge-proof capabilities ensure intense, long-lasting color that stays intact throughout the day.
Works well for the price and size
(+4)
This eyeliner stands out for its incredibly smooth and creamy application, allowing for effortless gliding to create any desired look. Its long-wearing, hyper-pigmented formula ensures an intensity that stays put for hours, even on the waterline.
Ultra-pigmented gel eyeliner
(+4)
This eyeliner stands out for its ultra-creamy texture, which allows for flawless glide and effortless, precise application. Its intense pigmentation delivers rich, bold color in a single swipe, and its formula is smudge-resistant, ensuring long-lasting wear.
Smudge-proof
(+4)
This eyeliner stands out for its exceptionally smooth application and high pigmentation, allowing for effortless gliding even on the waterline. It offers a solid wear time of up to 6 hours without smudging, maintaining intense color and beautiful dimension in the eyes.
Goes on smoothly
(+4)
This eyeliner offers a creamy texture that glides on smoothly, allowing for easy application and intense color. Its formula is blendable initially for creating smoky looks, but then sets for long-lasting, water-resistant wear, without melting throughout the day.
Amazing quality
(+4)
This eyeliner stands out for its ultra-smooth, creamy formula that allows for drag-proof application, delivering intense color and high pigmentation. Its waterproof and smudge-proof properties ensure exceptional longevity, keeping the look flawless for hours without smudging or transferring.
Brightens eyes
(+3)
This eyeliner stands out for its soft, creamy texture that allows for effortless application on the waterline, instantly brightening the eyes. Its high-quality formula ensures exceptional, all-day wear, maintaining intense color and a semi-matte finish.
Our ranking of creamy eyeliners is compiled from a comprehensive analysis of recommendations and experiences shared by the community and relevant sources. We focus on highlighting products that truly make a difference in daily use.