Best pizza places in Tampa

Santoro's Pizzeria was a finalist in the 'Best Pizzeria' category at Tampa Magazine's 'Best Restaurants 2025' awards and has been mentioned in lists of the city's best pizzerias in 2026.

Cappy's Pizzeria is very popular in the Tampa Bay area, known for its deep-dish pizza. It has been recognized as 'Best Pizzeria' by Tampa Magazine in 2026, which highlights its quality and popularity.

New York, New York Pizza is a pizzeria with multiple locations in Tampa, a finalist in the 'Best Restaurants 2025' awards and voted by readers in 2026. Its consistency and popularity make it a reliable choice.

This pizzeria is a landmark in downtown Tampa, recognized for its authentic New York-style crust. It has been awarded 'Best Pizzeria' by Tampa Magazine in 2025 and 2026, solidifying its reputation.

Forbici Modern Italian offers a unique pizza style, described as a fusion of Detroit, Sicilian, and Grandma. It was a finalist in Tampa Magazine's 'Best Restaurants' awards in 2025 and 2026, and received a high score from Dave Portnoy.

Bella's Italian Café is known for its homemade Neapolitan pizza and its ideal ambiance for dates. It was a winner in the 'Best Pizzeria' category by Tampa Magazine in 2025 and voted by readers in 2026.

Via Italia Woodfired Pizza & Bar is recognized for its wood-fired pizza, which gives it a distinctive flavor. It was highlighted by Restaurant Guru in March 2026 as one of Tampa's best pizzerias.

Best NY Pizza has been voted 'Best Pizza in Tampa' by Creative Loafing and 'Best Pizza in Tampa Bay' by the Tampa Bay Times. Its commitment to authenticity and quality makes it a top choice.

Tampa Pizza Company calls itself the 'Best Pizza Restaurant in Florida' and offers a wide range of options, including vegan and gluten-free pizzas. Its versatility and quality make it a popular choice.

Fabrica Pizza serves authentic Neapolitan pizza and has been ranked among the top 50 pizzerias in the United States by the '50 Top Pizza Guide'. Its commitment to quality and freshness makes it a standout choice.

Alfonso's has been a Tampa classic since 1978, where everything is homemade, from the dough to the sauce. It is famous for its garlic knots and has maintained an excellent reputation over the decades.

Founded by Tampa firefighters, Hot Rocks Pizza offers the best pizza with fresh ingredients and a complete menu of Philadelphia classics. It was mentioned in March 2026 as one of the top 10 pizzerias in Tampa by Restaurant Guru.

Flippers Pizza South Tampa is known for its all-natural artisan pizza, with homemade sauces and dressings. Its dough is cold-fermented for over 96 hours, ensuring exceptional flavor.

Gourmet Pizza Company is recognized for its quality and was mentioned in March 2026 as one of the top 10 pizzerias in Tampa by Restaurant Guru. Its focus on high-quality ingredients makes it stand out.

Noventa Millas: Cuban Pizzeria offers a unique Cuban pizza concept in Tampa, standing out for its distinctive flavors and a menu that includes spaghetti and milkshakes. It's a different and culturally rich option.

UNCLE MIKE'S PIZZERIA is a popular choice in Tampa, recognized by Restaurant Guru in March 2026 as one of the city's top 10 pizzerias. Its reputation is built on customer satisfaction.

Colony Grill is famous for its super-thin crust pizza and unique creations, such as the Chick-fil-A pizza. It is a prominent spot in Midtown Tampa, known for offering the largest pizza in the Bay area.

Reziero's NY Pizza is one of the standout pizzerias in Tampa, mentioned by Restaurant Guru in March 2026. It offers the authentic taste of New York pizza to the city's residents.