Best NHL captains

Sidney Crosby is the longest-tenured captain in the NHL, having led the Pittsburgh Penguins for nearly two decades. His consistent high-level play and ability to set the standard for his team make him an unparalleled leader.

Alex Ovechkin is the second-longest tenured captain in the NHL, known for his joyful yet intense leadership style. He continues to be a significant offensive force, reaching his 900th career goal in November 2025, showcasing his sustained impact.

Connor McDavid, named captain at the youngest age in NHL history, is widely considered the 'current GOAT' due to his elite skill and demanding pace. He consistently leads the league in points and assists, driving his team's performance.

Aleksander Barkov leads the Florida Panthers with quiet discipline and exceptional two-way play, earning multiple Selke and King Clancy Trophies. His complete captaincy, combining defensive responsibility with offensive contribution, makes him a true leader.

Roman Josi, captain of the Nashville Predators, leads with exceptional pace and pride, consistently demonstrating high impact on the ice. He is recognized as a franchise cornerstone and a highly effective captain.

Anze Kopitar has led the Los Angeles Kings with calm and consistent control for many years, maintaining high output throughout his career. His decision to announce retirement early in the 2025-26 season demonstrated leadership by preventing future distractions.

Gabriel Landeskog's leadership for the Colorado Avalanche endures despite injury setbacks, demonstrating his profound presence and influence. He remains a highly valued captain, crucial to the team's identity and success.

Jamie Benn leads the Dallas Stars with a distinct edge, contributing to the team's intensity and competitive spirit. As a veteran leader and key player, his impactful captaincy is recognized for driving team performance.

Jordan Staal leads the Carolina Hurricanes with a calm and steady demeanor, maintaining composure under pressure. His consistent and reliable leadership is a significant asset, providing stability and guidance to the team.

Anders Lee leads the New York Islanders through action and clutch plays, demonstrating durability and consistent production. His ability to score game-winning goals and his reliable presence make him an impactful captain.

Auston Matthews, a superstar and cornerstone of the Toronto Maple Leafs, was named captain in 2024. His elite skill and leadership are crucial for the team's success, making him a pivotal figure for the franchise.

Nico Hischier is a very good player and a great leader in the locker room for the New Jersey Devils. His captaincy, established in 2021, marks him as a current star and a key leader for the team's future.

Brady Tkachuk is a significant and impactful leader for the Ottawa Senators, having been named captain in 2021. His presence and leadership are essential for the team's identity and competitive drive.

J.T. Miller was appointed the newest captain in the NHL in September 2025, signifying his recognized leadership qualities within the New York Rangers organization. His recent appointment highlights his immediate impact and importance to the team.