Music

Covers of songs that surpassed their originals

Explore a fascinating list of song covers that, in popular opinion, surpassed their originals. Discover how talented artists have reinvented classics, giving them new life and resonance. This ranking celebrates the creativity and ability of cover versions to overshadow initial recordings, sparking passionate debates among music fans. Dive into this musical journey and decide which of these interpretations you like best. It's a perfect opportunity to rediscover hits and appreciate the evolution of music through different voices and styles.

699100% verified
  1. 1

    Always On My Mind (Pet Shop Boys)

    315 Global Votes
    • Masterpiece of electronic-pop music

    The Pet Shop Boys' version is much more popular and recognizable than Brenda Lee's original. Their synth-pop style gave it a unique touch and turned it into an '80s classic.

  2. 2

    Hallelujah (Jeff Buckley)

    272 Global Votes
    • Definitive, aching, pure, and haunting rendition

      (+4)

    Jeff Buckley's interpretation of this Leonard Cohen song is considered one of the best versions of all time. His angelic voice and the emotion he conveys make it a very special version.

  3. 3

    Walk On By (The Stranglers)

    112 Global Votes
    • Covered in 124 songs

      (+1)

    The Stranglers gave a punk twist to the original song by Burt Bacharach and Hal David, performed by Dionne Warwick. Their version is more energetic and has a distinctive sound.

  4. 4

    Hurt by Johnny Cash

    0 Global Votes
    • Stripped-down acoustic arrangement

      (+3)

    Although the original is by Nine Inch Nails, Johnny Cash's interpretation is considered by many to be superior. His raspy voice and the emotion he conveys make it an iconic version.

  5. 5

    All Along the Watchtower (Jimi Hendrix)

    0 Global Votes
    • Masterpiece that Bob Dylan preferred to his own

      (+2)

    Jimi Hendrix's version of Bob Dylan's song is legendary. His guitar virtuosity and the intensity he brings to it make it one of the best versions in history.

  6. All the rankings you can imagine

    Thousands of verified votes to discover the best. Your vote here counts

  7. 6

    I Will Always Love You — Dolly Parton

    0 Global Votes
    • Whitney Houston's version was a critical success.

    Dolly Parton's original composition is a country masterpiece that, although acclaimed, was eclipsed in massive popularity by Whitney Houston's iconic version.

  8. 7

    'Respect'

    0 Global Votes
    • She turned it into a feminist anthem

      (+2)

    Otis Redding's original version of "Respect" is a powerful expression of a man's demands for respect in his relationship, laying the groundwork for the iconic later version.

  9. 8

    Hurt - Nine Inch Nails

    0 Global Votes
    • He transformed the industrial song into a raw and heartbreaking ballad

      (+2)

    Nine Inch Nails' original version of 'Hurt', written by Trent Reznor, is a powerful expression of pain and despair that laid the groundwork for its later reinterpretation.

  10. 9

    Nothing Compares 2 U by Sinéad O'Connor

    0 Global Votes
    • It was named the number one single worldwide by Billboard.

      (+1)

    Sinéad O'Connor's rendition of "Nothing Compares 2 U" is widely regarded as a version that eclipsed the original, bringing a raw emotional depth and iconic vocal delivery that made it a global hit and an enduring anthem.

  11. 10

    Jeff Buckley

    0 Global Votes
    • His version of Hallelujah is considered one of the best

      (+2)

    Jeff Buckley's version of "Hallelujah" is widely regarded as one of the most emotional and acclaimed performances, often eclipsing the popularity of the original.

  12. 11

    Robert Hazard

    0 Global Votes
    • Cover song

    Robert Hazard composed and recorded the original demo of 'Girls Just Want to Have Fun' in 1979, laying the groundwork for the song's future success.

  13. 12

    Ednaswap

    0 Global Votes
    • Song that has been covered several times.

    Ednaswap is the band that originally wrote and recorded 'Torn' in 1993. Their version laid the groundwork for the song, although Imbruglia's version achieved much greater commercial success.

  14. 13

    Mad World

    0 Global Votes

    Puddles Pity Party and Haley Reinhart's Postmodern Jukebox-style version reimagines 'Mad World' in a vintage Vaudeville style, offering a unique and theatrical take on the song.

  15. 14

    Valerie

    0 Global Votes
    • The version by Mark Ronson and Amy Winehouse became more successful than the original.

      (+1)

    The Zutons' original song, released in 2006, laid the groundwork for their subsequent massive success through later versions.

  16. 15

    Tainted Love

    0 Global Votes
    • It conquered the charts

      (+3)

    Soft Cell's version of "Tainted Love" became an '80s synth-pop anthem, eclipsing Gloria Jones' original 1964 recording with its distinctive sound and commercial success.

  17. 16

    I Love Rock 'n' Roll

    0 Global Votes
    • Their cover is better than Arrow's original.

      (+1)

    Joan Jett's version of "I Love Rock 'n' Roll" surpassed The Arrows' original in popularity and commercial success, becoming an 80s rock anthem.

  18. 17

    The Arrows

    0 Global Votes
    • The original version of "I Love Rock 'n' Roll"

    The Arrows recorded the original version of "I Love Rock 'n' Roll" in 1975. Although their version did not reach the same level of fame, it laid the groundwork for future success.

  19. 18

    The Isley Brothers

    0 Global Votes
    • It gave it a sound very similar to the song we know today from Twist and Shout.

    The Isley Brothers recorded an influential version of 'Twist and Shout' that popularized the song before The Beatles made their own iconic rendition.

  20. 19

    The Bobby Fuller Four

    0 Global Votes
    • He had a top 10 hit with the song in 1966

      (+1)

    The Bobby Fuller Four's version of 'I Fought the Law' was a hit that took it to the top ten in 1966, popularizing the song and being considered by many as the definitive version before The Clash.

  21. 20

    Hound Dog

    0 Global Votes
    • Popularized by Elvis Presley

      (+1)

    Big Mama Thornton's version of "Hound Dog" is a powerful and raw blues rendition that laid the foundation for rock and roll. Her powerful voice and bold style gave the song an energy that influenced countless artists.

  22. 21

    Killing Me Softly With His Song

    0 Global Votes
    • The Fugees' version surpassed the original.

      (+1)

    The Fugees' version of "Killing Me Softly With His Song" became a massive hit, surpassing Roberta Flack's original version in popularity and recognition and establishing itself as a 90s anthem.

  23. 22

    Red Red Wine

    0 Global Votes
    • A global hit that revived Neil Diamond.

    UB40's version of "Red Red Wine" became a massive worldwide hit, surpassing Neil Diamond's original 1967 acoustic ballad in popularity and recognition, thanks to its distinctive reggae style and the addition of a verse by Astro.

  24. 23

    Always On My Mind

    0 Global Votes
    • Voted the best cover of all time in a BBC poll

      (+2)

    Pet Shop Boys' version of "Always On My Mind" was voted the best cover of all time in a BBC Music poll, beating the original.